Top 3 Lures for Catching Monster Pike!

Posted by Scott Sibley on

If you’re like us you love the fight of a monster pike at the end of your line. Pike are big, hungry and can be super aggressive. When the pike are biting they’ll eat up pretty much whatever you throw in the water, but what do you do when they aren’t so active.  Here is a list of the top 3 lures to use when the getting gets tough.


  1. Rapala X-Rap
Rapala X-Rap Gold






The X-Rap is a main stay in pike tackle boxes around Canada, and for good reason. They cast far, can be retrieved at variable speeds or twitched to create a wounded baitfish swimming action.  They also include Rapalas classic rattle that can be heard from a distance if the water is murky. If pike are lazy, retrieve with a stop and go, pausing to let your lure suspend in the strike zone. It won’t be long until you start a tug of war with a hug pike.

  1. Len Thompson 5 of Diamonds
5 of Diamonds Kit

Len Thompson keeps producing winners and there is no greater winner than the 5 of diamonds. This spoon produces cast after cast after cast.  Size 00 is our favorite size of the spoon. It’s easy to cast and the side to side action on the retrieve is like no other. A steady retrieve usually works wonders but if it doesn’t work for you try jerking the spoon a few times during the retrieve. That will bring the spoon up and then let fall for 1-2 seconds and jerk again, that is when you’ll get your fish on.

  1. Mepps Black Fury
Mepps-Black Fury

Last but not least, the Black Fury. I personally like the #3, It works over and over again for me, but if you believe the rule bigger lure bigger fish  than you’re in luck, Mepps makes larger sizes and some specifically for pike and musky. Some people also like to remove the hook and replace it with a larger one, again, that’s preference and totally up to the angler. This spinner covers a ton of water and with the yellow colour spin pattern it gets noticed. We usually fish this lure with a steady retrieve but it is such a versatile lure that you can experiment and not worry about missing your chance.


We know there are many other lures that can be added to this list and some people will disagree with our choices. So let’s open this up for discussion. Leave a comment and let us know what you would add or subtract from the list.

Len Thompson Mepps Musky Pike Rapala

← Older Post Newer Post →

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

★Angler Reviews

Angler Reviews

218 reviews
Nice toque

Its very nice specially the part where it says ”simple fishing “ at the front

Elite Trial Multi-Fishing box

Son-in- law loved his Christmas box. Can’t wait to receive the February one and see what goodies he gets.

Great Gift!

I got a subscription for my son 15 years old who LOVES fishing I saved 2 boxes and gave them to him on Christmas, he was very happy said it was the best gift!😁👍

I'm so glad I found Simple Fishing and the RLM Elite box!

I've been receiving the Pike box for under a year now. It is the only subscription tackle box I've found that offers a box targeted to Norther Pike. And I love these boxes. Great baits. Great value! Especially with the USD exchange! I even made an unboxing video because I like these so much. ( )

Awesome gift

Got for my father for Christmas arrived fast and I think he will love it. Look forward to the next two boxes!